DEV: Keyer Efficiency

The tables below show the number of strokes (there and back) required to send each character with a straight key, bug, single-lever paddle, or dual-lever paddle (using an ultimatic or iambic keyer). The best and worst counts for each character are highlighted. The iambic keyer is the most efficient for every character, and the straight key is the least efficient for every character but there is not much difference between the ultimatic and iambic keyers, and of course other factors may override pure efficiency. It's worth noting that, owing to the design of Morse code, the most common English language characters (E, T, A, O, I, N) are all efficient to send with any key type (with the exception of O on a straight key perhaps).

For more information on keyers see Keyers: Iambic and Ultimatic, and for an introduction to the different physical key types, see Straight Keys, Bugs, Paddles, Sounders and Keyers. You might also want to try an emulated keyer.

This analysis was inspired by this document by K7QO, which includes stroke count analysis (and unfortunately includes an arithmetic error in adding up the stroke counts for the bug).

Sound Controls
 
 
 
LettersMorse CodeStraightBugSingle-LeverIambicUltimatic
Adi-dah22222
Bdah-di-di-dit42222
Cdah-di-dah-dit44423
Ddah-di-dit32222
Edit11111
Fdi-di-dah-dit43322
Gdah-dah-dit33222
Hdi-di-di-dit41111
Idi-dit21111
Jdi-dah-dah-dah44222
Kdah-di-dah33322
Ldi-dah-di-dit43322
Mdah-dah22111
Ndah-dit22222
Odah-dah-dah33111
Pdi-dah-dah-dit44332
Qdah-dah-di-dah44322
Rdi-dah-dit33322
Sdi-di-dit31111
Tdah11111
Udi-di-dah32222
Vdi-di-di-dah42222
Wdi-dah-dah33222
Xdah-di-di-dah43332
Ydah-di-dah-dah44322
Zdah-dah-di-dit43222
Total8266554746
DigitsMorse CodeStraightBugSingle-LeverIambicUltimatic
1di-dah-dah-dah-dah55222
2di-di-dah-dah-dah54222
3di-di-di-dah-dah53222
4di-di-di-di-dah52222
5di-di-di-di-dit51111
6dah-di-di-di-dit52222
7dah-dah-di-di-dit53222
8dah-dah-dah-di-dit54222
9dah-dah-dah-dah-dit55222
0dah-dah-dah-dah-dah55111
Total5034181818
OtherMorse CodeStraightBugSingle-LeverIambicUltimatic
.di-dah-di-dah-di-dah66624
,dah-dah-di-di-dah-dah65332
/dah-di-di-dah-dit54433
?di-di-dah-dah-di-dit64332
<AR>di-dah-di-dah-dit55523
<SK>di-di-di-dah-di-dah64423
<BT>dah-di-di-di-dah53332
<BK>dah-di-di-di-dah-di-dah75533
Total4636332122

Across all the characters above, the total stroke counts are:

We can list the characters in order of stroke count for each key type:

Straight key stroke count:

  1. E T
  2. A I M N
  3. D G K O R S U W
  4. B C F H J L P Q V X Y Z
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 / <AR> <BT>
  6. . , ? <SK>
  7. <BK>

Bug stroke count:

  1. E H I S T 5
  2. A B D M N U V 4 6
  3. F G K L O R W X Z 3 7 <BT>
  4. C J P Q Y 2 8 / ? <SK>
  5. 1 9 0 , <AR> <BK>
  6. .

Single-lever stroke count:

  1. E H I M O S T 5 0
  2. A B D G J N U V W Z 1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9
  3. F K L P Q R X Y , ? <BT>
  4. C / <SK>
  5. <AR> <BK>
  6. .

Iambic stroke count:

  1. E H I M O S T 5 0
  2. A B C D F G J K L N Q R U V W Y Z 1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9 . <AR> <SK>
  3. P X , / ? <BT> <BK>

Ultimatic stroke count:

  1. E H I M O S T 5 0
  2. A B D F G J K L N P Q R U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9 , ? <BT>
  3. C / <AR> <SK> <BK>
  4. .